- Holding hands
- Take a good look at this picture. It's one of the most
remarkable photographs ever taken. The tiny hand of a foetus reaches out
from a mother's womb to clasp a surgeon's healing finger. It is, by the
way, 21 weeks old, an age at which it could still be legally aborted. The
tiny hand in the picture above belongs to a baby which is due to be born
on December 28. It was taken during an operation in America recently. Paul
Harris reports on a medical development in the control of the effects of
spina bifida ... and on a picture which will reverberate through the on-going
abortion debate here
- Your first instinct is to recoil in horror.
It looks like a close-up of some terrible accident. And then you notice,
in the centre of the photograph, the tiny hand clutching a surgeon's finger.
- The baby is literally hanging on for life. For this is
one of the most remarkable photographs taken in medicine and a record of
one of the world's most extraordinary operations.
- It shows a 21-week-old foetus in its mother's womb, about
to undergo a spine operation designed to save it from serious brain damage.
- The surgery was carried out entirely through the tiny
slit visible in the wall of the womb and the `patient' is believed to be
the youngest to undergo it.
- At that age the mother could have chosen to have the
foetus aborted. Her decision not to, however, led to an astonishing test
not just of medical technology, but of faith.
- Samuel Armas has spina bifida, which left part of his
spinal cord exposed after the backbone failed to develop.
- The operation was designed to close the gap and protect
the cord, the body's motorway for nerve signals to the brain.
- So, on an unborn patient no bigger than a guinea-pig,
the operation was performed without removing the foetus from the womb.
- The instruments had to be specially designed to work
in miniature. The sutures used to close the incisions were less than the
thickness of a human hair.
- An ER-style crash-cart team was on constant standby in
an adjoining room.
- When it was completed, however, Samuel's battle for survival
was only just beginning. Nor would the emotional battle his parents had
already endured finish quite yet.
- Julie and Alex Armas had been trying desperately for
a baby. Julie, a 27-year-old nurse, had suffered two miscarriages before
she became pregnant with the child they intended to call Samuel Alexander
if it was a boy.
- Then, at 14 weeks, she started to suffer terrible cramp.
An ultrasound scan was carried out to show the shape of the developing
foetus and its position in the womb.
- When the picture emerged, it was the moment that every
parent-to-be dreads. Their unborn son's brain was mis-shapen and his spinal
cord was sticking out from a deformed backbone. He had spina bifida. They
were devastated and ``torn apart'' said Alex, a 28-year-old jet aircraft
- At that stage, and even weeks later, the couple could
have decided to have the pregnancy terminated. In their home town of Georgia
in the US as in Britain abortion is routinely offered. Although accurate
figures are not available, many parents accept. For Julie and Alex, who
are deeply religious, it was not an option.
- That didn't mean, of course, that they were not racked
by pain at the thought that the child they had longed for was imperfect.
- It also riddled them with guilt over whether they had
effectively taken the decision to inflict their son with years of handicap,
pain and suffering.
- So, this being the United States, they turned to the
internet for help.
- Julie's mother found a website giving details of pioneering
surgery being carried out by a team at Vanderbilt University in Nashville,
Tennessee. Although the results have not yet been endorsed in medical journals,
they looked encouraging to Mr. And Mrs. Armas.
- Their doctor put them in touch with Dr. Joseph Bruner
(it is his finger in the photograph). A race against time had begun.
- Because it affects the spinal cord, spina bifida can
lead to a condition that causes brain damage. Mr and Mrs. Armas were told
that if they were to avoid the condition, which was not then present in
Samuel, they had to act fast.
- ``I wasn't concerned about a child who couldn't walk,''
said Julie, ``but I want a child who knows me.''
- The theory behind the surgery is that attention to he
spine disorder before the baby is born prevents or limits brain damage,
and gives a better chance of healing. It does not cure spina bifida, but
it is said to provide a strong chance of limiting the damage through early
- The risks, however, are enormous. Controversy surrounds
the use of such surgery because it goes against the general medical rule
that the risk should not outweigh the benefit.
- Mr and Mrs Armas were fully aware that if anything went
wrong, no attempt would be made to deliver Samuel by Caesarean section.
- Medical science does not yet have the capability to keep
a 21-week-old foetus alive outside the womb. The crash-cart was on standby
for Julie, not Samuel.
- ``If he dies, that's horrible for me and for us,'' said
Julie before she went into theatre. Wiping tears she added: ``But not for
him. The worst thing might be if we don't do this, and this is standard
treatment when he's 21, and he says: ``Why didn't you know about that?''
And we say: ``We did, but we didn't do it for you.''
- The other major dangers were turning him in the womb
to get his back in line with an inch-long cut in the wall, through which
Dr Bruner would operate, and that the surgery might involve releasing the
fluid around Samuel.
- The movement posed the risk of sending Julie into labour
contractions, which would have been fatal for Samuel.
- Thus, one morning at the beginning of last month, Dr
Bruner could be heard urging his team to keep quiet. ``Shh!'' he said.
``You'll wake the baby!''
- Robert Davis, who reported on the operation for USA Today
newspaper, said the lesion that exposed Samuel's spine was found low on
his backbone, decreasing the chance of nerve damage.
- Although Samuel is believed to have been the youngest
patient for such an operation, it was apparently routine enough for Dr
Bruner and paediatric neurosurgeon Noel Tullpant to talk about the weather
during the operation.
- An hour later, the womb is gently eased back into place.
``Beautiful,'' said one of the technicians and relief swept the room.
- Julie was allowed home with Alex within days. The baby
is due on December 28.
- He has not yet felt the touch of his mother's skin against
his own and he knows nothing of life outside her womb. But perhaps Samuel
Alexander Armas will be able to shake Dr Bruner's hand again.
- The calm before the abortion debate storm
- By Justine McCarthyNobody could be unmoved by the powerful
image of this tiny finger clinging to the surgeon's hand. A hand that can
create modern miracles and save lives that might otherwise be doomed before
they even begin. This picture is an emotive and compelling argument against
the termination of abnormal pregnancies and it appears as Ireland braces
itself for yet another visitation of the debate.
- As the range of options outlined in the government Green
Paper are being considered for the next instalment in the Irish debate,
there is a sense of an uneasy calm before the storm. With assisted abortion
technically legal here under the Supreme Court ruling in the X Case, pro-life
organisations still continue to lobby for yet another referendum on the
- Dana's election to the European parliament last summer
was indicative of the strong pro-life undercurrent in her constituency
of Connacht-Ulster. Suggestions that similar candidates might be fielded
throughout the country at the next general election are predicated on the
belief that a referendum is still a possibility.
- In fact, Dana indirectly raised the subject in Europe
this week when she put down an amendment to the Union's budget seeking
to end the funding monopoly enjoyed by the European Women's Lobby. She
wanted to give some of the allocated £480,000 to the World Movement
of Mothers, an organisation Dana claimed to know little about but which
others described as pro-life. The European Women's Lobby, an umbrella organisation
that lobbies the EU on behalf of various womens groups throughout the Union,
claimed that the proposed cut in its funding could jeopardise the jobs
of its 10-strong staff.
- Though, ultimately, no vote was taken on that amendment,
it focussed the parliament's minds on the issue of abortion once again.
- Nearly 6,000 Irish females are expected to travel to
Britain this year for abortions. In this country, however, the debate has
traditionally been concerned with crisis pregnancies rather than abnormal
foetal development. In that respect, this extraordinary photograph may
have more relevance to the debate in Britain where termination is legally
available at 21 weeks - the age of the world's youngest known patient.
- Drudge, Fox in Conflict Over Fetus