For decades, Palestinians
have been slaughtered, displaced, intimidated, humiliated, collectively
punished, and denied equal rights as Jews. They've also been mass imprisoned.
Palestine is Israeli occupied territory. Military orders govern all
aspects of daily life. Democratic rights are denied. Freedom is a non-starter,
persecution a way of life.
Gaza is an open-air prison. The West Bank and East Jerusalem fare little
better. Life in Occupied Palestine for about 4.2 million residents is
hell. No one's safe from Israel's wrath.
According to the Addameer Prisoner Support group, over 700,000 Palestinians
were imprisoned since June 1967. Over 20% of the population was affected.
For males, it's 40%. For women, it's about 10,000 and for children around
7,000 since 2000 alone.
No other country comes close to these figures. None calling themselves
democracies would dare. With the world's largest prison population by
far, America comes closest.
Mostly affected are Blacks, Latinos, and Muslims since Washington declared
war on Islam. In America and Israel, praying to the wrong God is hazardous.
Palestinian prisoner numbers vary. Thousands are affected at all times.
Virtually all are political prisoners. Arabs aren't welcome in Israel.
In Palestine they're equated with terrorists.
Pre-dawn raids, arrests, false charges, harsh interrogations, torture,
intimidation, rigged trials, and imprisonment terrorize them. Children
young as 10 are affected. So is everyone wanting to live free on their
own land in their own country. Perhaps one day, but not now.
Israel holds Palestinians in 17 prisons, four interrogation centers,
and another four for shorter-term detentions. All but one are in Israel
in violation of Fourth Geneva's Article 76. It states:
"Protected persons accused of offences shall be detained in the occupied
country, and if convicted they shall serve their sentences therein."
Proper treatment is also covered. Israel spurns all international law
obligations. Palestinian prisoners suffer most.
Military orders divide criminality into five categories:
(1) "Hostile Terrorist Activity"
(2) Disturbance of public order
(3) "Classic" criminal offenses
(4) Illegal presence in Israel
(5) Traffic offenses
Broadly defined ones criminalize "many aspects of Palestinian civic
life." For example, belong to the wrong political party and risk prosecution.
Displaying a Palestinian flag is criminalized.
Peacefully demonstrating is considered disrupting public order. "Pouring
coffee for a member of a declared illegal association can be seen as
support for a terrorist organization."
So can dozens of other non-threatening aspects of daily life conducted
freely in real democracies. Not in Palestine, and increasingly also
risky in America.
Prison life for Palestinians is hell. Horrific conditions include severe
overcrowding, poor ventilation and sanitation, no change of clothes
or adequate clothing, wooden planks with thin mattresses and filthy
blankets, inadequate food in terms of quality, quantity or conformance
with dietary requirements, poor medical care, and restricted or no access
to family members and counsel, among other abuses.
Isolation is worse. Alone or with one other prisoner, lockdown runs
23 hours daily. Most cells are 1.5 by 2 meters to 3 by 3.5. Little light
or air gets in. It's almost like being entombed. International law is
Under Article 10 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political
"All persons deprived of their liberty shall be treated with humanity
and with respect for the inherent dignity of the human person."
In or out of prison, Palestinians are denied all rights. The Standard
Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners explicitly states isolation
for punishment should be infrequent and of limited duration. Under Article
"Corporal punishment, punishment by placing in a dark cell, and all
cruel, inhuman or degrading punishments shall be completely prohibited
as punishments for disciplinary offences."
The Basic Principles for the Treatment of Prisoners encourage the restriction
or abolition of isolation as punishment.
When imposed, strict rules govern treatment Israel spurns with impunity.
Whether isolated or part of the general prison population, Palestinians
are treated horrifically.
Denied virtually all rights, they use the only one remaining. Refusing
food is their weapon of choice. Growing numbers employ it. On April
17, over 1,200 Palestinian prisoners began hunger striking for justice.
On April 24, the International Middle East Media Center estimated around
3,000 "as (growing) waves of detainees" demand international law guaranteed
Many call it "the battle of empty bowels." They demand better conditions
and treatment. They include ending torture, ill-treatment, administrative
detention, isolation, night raids, humiliating/invasive searches, and
other forms of abuses.
They also want family visitations and access to counsel. Most of all,
they want freedom. Being Palestinian got them imprisoned. So did nonviolently
resisting occupation, persecution, land theft, and colonization of their
Palestinian Prisoners Society (PPS) head Qaddoura Fares said some administrative
detainees reached the "no return point." They've been hunger striking
over 50 days and won't quit until free.
Others show equal resolve. Israel reacted as expected by cracking down
harder. Palestinian Prisoners Club representative Amani Sarahna said
"(a)ll prisoners' belongings were confiscated except their towels and
Organizers called for supportive Gaza and West Bank rallies. Sustained
efforts outside and within prison walls draw widespread attention and
have the best chance of changing what shouldn't be tolerated anywhere.
Prisoners' only outside links are family members and counsel. Denial
of either violates international law.
On April 17, the Adalah Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel
and Al Mezan Center for Human Rights discussed denying access to counsel
to exert pressure on Palestinian prisoners.
"The right of a detainee to meet with and be represented by an attorney
has long been recognized as a basic constitutional right, one which
derives from an individualís rights to personal liberty, dignity and
due process," they said.
In Sufian v. Commander of IDF Forces in Gaza, Israel's Supreme Court
recognized this right. Moreover, it disqualified evidence obtained by
violating it. However, the Court stopped short of including so-called
"security detainees." They're heroic, not criminals.
As a result, Israel inflicts harsher treatment. It includes denying
access to counsel. Israel's High Court concurred. In the Sufian ruling,
it rejected petitioner's request for attorney/client meetings.
It argued that according to classified material, doing so would compromise
regional security and hamstring investigative procedures. The Court
left unexamined arrest and interrogation procedures. It chose only to
rule based on classified General Security Service (GSS) material.
ICCPR's Article 14:
"All persons shall be equal before the courts and tribunals."
"To be tried in his presence, and to defend himself in person or through
legal assistance of his own choosing; to be informed, if he does not
have legal assistance, of this right; and to have legal assistance assigned
Right to counsel doesn't end behind bars. It derives from the recognized
right to personal liberty, dignity, due process, and judicial fairness.
Israel's Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty protects both rights from
"deprivation or restriction of the liberty of a person by imprisonment,
arrest, extradition or otherwise."
Everyone is "entitled to protection of their life, body and dignity."
The right to counsel is universally recognized. America's Sixth Amendment
mandates it. No democracy excludes. Doing so violates a fundamental
Israel targets Palestinians it wants denied any chance for justice.
Israel's no democracy. It keeps finding new ways proving it.
A Final Comment
Through February 2012 the Israel Prison Service (IPS) held 4,631 security
prisoners, according to Adalah. They're held "under much harsher and
more severe detention conditions than criminal prisoners."
As explained above, Israel's Supreme Court lets the IPS distinguish
between both categories and inflict pain accordingly. At the same time,
the Court said "the IPS should balance prisoners' rights with restrictions
necessary to maintain security." How it didn't say.
Security prisoners may or may not receive family visits. Gazans are
entirely denied. If permitted, only first-degree relatives are included.
All telephone contacts are prohibited. So is permission to leave prison
temporarily in cases of first degree family member deaths.
Security prisoners' social needs are ignored. Excluded are education
and rehabilitation services. So is amnesty from Israel's president or
reduction of life sentences.
In 2011, restrictions were further tightened. Conditions worsened. Netanyahu
publicly said measures were adopted to exacerbate prison harshness.
More than ever, cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment is policy.
Hunger strikers face collective punishment. All rights were denied them.
Dozens were moved to isolated southern Negev's Nafha Prison.
Its Section 4 cells are described as "dirty, dark, and unventilated,
with insects and cockroaches crawling from mattresses."
Prisoners' health and well-being are endangered. They told Adalah about
crowded small cells with poor sanitation and no separation between toilets
and showers. Vermin infests them. Blackouts regularly occur.
Adalah petitioned IPS. It demanded Section 4 be closed. Two letters
weren't answered. At end of March, prisoners were transferred to another
area just as bad.
Adalah called their treatment "a new form of collective punishment."
Treating Palestinians harshly "is characteristic of IPS' security prisoner
Pain and suffering is featured. Rule of law principles are ignored.
Police state cruelty substitutes for what even Israeli law mandates.
When it comes to Palestinians, nothing is too abusive to impose.
Stephen Lendman lives in Chicago and can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Also visit his blog site at sjlendman.blogspot.com and listen to cutting-edge
discussions with distinguished guests on the Progressive Radio News
Hour on the Progressive Radio Network Thursdays at 10AM US Central time
and Saturdays and Sundays at noon. All programs are archived for easy