- At any time, from 7,000 - 12,000 or more Palestinians
are politically persecuted and imprisoned, including young children. The
Addameer Prisoners' Support and Human Rights Association explains that
for over 43 years under military occupation, over 650,000 Palestinians
have been illegally detained for wanting freedom on their own land in their
own country, what Israel won't tolerate, nor have its leaders ever wanted
peace. Saying so is a lie.
- What Avi Shlaim once said about Ariel Sharon, applies
to virtually all other Israeli leaders, past and present; namely, that
"Bargaining, accommodation, and compromise (were) alien to his whole
way of thinking."
- Sharon earlier, and Netanyahu today, share like-minded
views; namely, that "relations with the Palestinians (are) a zero-sum
game" in which Israel intends to gain at their expense, including
its own Arab citizens. Both leaders spurn concessions, Sharon once saying,
"This is our land, and we'll settle it and build on it in order to
prevent the creation of a Palestinian state. We'll never give up this area."
As a result, Palestinians have been ruthlessly persecuted, imprisoned,
or slaughtered in gross violation of international laws.
- Ameer Makoul is one of many victims, a previous article
about him accessed through the following link:
- An Israeli citizen, human rights activist, and head of
the internationally recognized Ittijah NGO for Palestinian empowerment,
he also chairs the Public Committee for the Defence of Political Prisoners
within the Arab Higher Monitoring Committee in Israel. Besides championing
human rights, he also supports the global BDS movement, what many believe
is perhaps the most effective nonviolent tactic against Israeli lawlessness,
and another reason for his targeting.
- An earlier article on Palestinian Political Prisoners
can be accessed through the link below:
- Makhoul's Ordeal
- In May, Makhoul was arrested on spurious charges of spying
for Hezbollah, Israel's way to silence a respected Palestinian. At the
time, attorney Hussein Abu Hasin said accusations were so vague and wide-ranging
that emails, Internet chats or phone conversations with anyone about anything
could be used as a pretext to prosecute for communicating with a "state
enemy," whether or not true and regardless of the right to speak freely
- At the time, Mohammed Zeidan, head of the Human Rights
Association of Nazareth said:
- "We are used to our political leaders being persecuted,
but now Shin Bet is turning its sights on the leaders of Palestinian civil
society in Israel, and that's a dangerous development." Based on suspicions,
circumstantial evidence, or none at all, Shin Bet's likely to target anyone
"unwittingly....meet(ing) a relative of a relative of someone in Hezbollah,
(Hamas, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, Islamic Jihad,
or the Iranian government as) grounds to arrest you." Activist leaders
are notably threatened, especially Israeli Arabs seen by hard liners as
a fifth column existential threat essential to crush.
- Zeidan believes that persecution of Israeli Arab society
is the best way to expose Israeli racism and discrimination against anyone
not Jewish. "Markhoul's arrest should be understood in that light."
- On May 6, his ordeal began when about 20 Israeli police
and security forces arrested him at 3:10AM, ransacked his apartment, confiscated
his computers, cell phones, various documents, maps, and other possessions.
At the same time, his Haifa office was also raided for other potentially
"incriminating" evidence, a Shin Bet warrant saying only that
"secret information" justified it for "security reasons,"
when, in fact, none whatsoever existed.
- On May 9, Ynetnews.com writer Sharon Roffe-Ofir headlined,
"Security scandal angers Arab sector," saying:
- Despite a gag order, aroused Israeli Arabs freely discussed
Israeli "police persecution of (the) Arab community....In Facebook,
a protest group has already been set up, and (days earlier) an emergency
conference was held by the Mossawa Center and the Adalah Center, both of
which are among the most prominent organizations working for Arab rights,"
along with many others expressing concern. Wide distribution of information
followed through newspapers, blogs, and word of mouth.
- Mossawa's director, Jafar Farah, called "the steps
taken by (Israel's) security establishment....an extreme right wing policy.
In democratic countries," this type lawlessness is prohibited. The
Popular Committee for the Defense of Freedoms said Israel's attack on freedom
"is at its height." MK Masud Ganaim (of United Arab List-Ta'al)
sent thousands of emails calling the affair:
- "police terror and silencing. What is happening
is clear proof of racism. Whoever claims Israel is the only democracy in
the Middle East gets new evidence to the contrary every day, in the steps
taken by the government and its institutions against citizens, parties
and organizations of the Arab sector."
- Makhoul was detained incommunicado at Petah Tikva for
interrogation. Under gag order (now lifted), the Israeli media couldn't
write or discuss anything about his case.
- He endured 12 days of brutal interrogation, including
torture and sleep deprivation. After three weeks, he was charged with espionage,
helping an enemy (Hezbollah) in time of war, contact with a foreign agent,
and other spurious charges, all of which he denied.
- On June 14, prosecutors claimed "secret evidence"
against him, withheld from his lawyers for "security reasons."
In addition, all attorney conversations were wiretapped, and despite requesting
medical help from the Association of Physicians for Human Rights, it was
- He remains imprisoned, a Committee for the Defense of
Ameer Makhoul established on September 8 to defend him. Comprised of dozens
of Jewish and Arab figures, it took collective responsibility because:
- -- his arrest signifies what he represents, not just
himself, and it was done to warn other activist Israeli Arabs; and
- -- charges against him are entirely unfounded and spurious,
his targeting to silence a respected, powerful, effective political voice
for all Arab Israeli citizens.
- He's represented them globally as an internationally
recognized human rights advocate, and as a member of world and regional
coalitions and networks. Speaking publicly or in any other way to anyone
is protected speech, yet accusations against him violate his legitimate
right to communicate freely with Arab colleagues.
- On September 16, he was charged in Haifa District Court,
even though Israeli prosecutors said his home and office computers, cell
phones, other possessions, and transcripts of about 30,000 wiretapped phone
conversations revealed no evidence of espionage.
- On September 14, his lawyers got the Nazareth District
Court to uphold his right to direct and confidential counsel access, what
he previously was denied in violation of Israeli and international law.
Earlier in 2009, Shin Bet said they'd "tailor a file for this disappearance
and prolonged separation from his family" unless he softened his outspoken
activism, including his denunciation of Cast Lead war crimes.
- Human rights groups, including Amnesty International
have been outspoken for him, AI signaling it may declare him a "prisoner
of conscience" because his arrest "smacks of pure harassment,
designed to hinder his human rights work."
- Ahead, the Committee for the Defense of Ameer Makhoul
needs help to raise funds, mobilize international legal and medical help
as well as observers for his trial. Some tactical victories have been won,
however, including disseminating information globally on his case and defeating
Israel's gag order. Remaining tasks include building a solid defense team,
challenging prosecutorial use of "secret evidence" unavailable
to counsel, as well as bogusly incriminating anyone for using protected
speech to communicate freely with anyone.
- A Final Comment
- Ahmad Sa'adat is another prominent Israeli political
prisoner, an earlier article on him accessed through the following link:
- He's the General Secretary of the Popular Front for the
Liberation of Palestine (PFLP), sentenced in 2002 to 30 years imprisonment
for supporting Palestinian liberation heroically.
- On October 4, an International Campaign for the Release
of Kidnapped Palestinian Legislators press release said he's spent over
"500 days in solitary confinement under the most inhumane conditions....to
break (his) will and steadfastness."
- Brutal torture, abuse and humiliation are longstanding
Israeli longstanding practices, including against children. In mid-October,
Sa'adat will challenge his isolation in court, as well as his overall inhumane
treatment, denying his basic rights, including:
- -- virtually no family and legal visits;
- -- isolation from other prisoners;
- -- only 30 minute daily prison yard access, in painful
handcuffs and ankle shackles;
- -- little reading material and no personal books;
- -- brutal interrogations, including physical and psychological
- -- no canteen purchases; and
- -- like other political prisoners, no proper food, medical
care, proper ventilation and sanitation, adequate clothing, or virtually
all other basic necessities for health and well-being, in violation of
fundamental international laws, including Geneva's Common Article 3 requiring:
- "humane treatment for all persons in enemy hands,
specifically prohibit(ing) murder, mutilation, torture, cruel, humiliating
and degrading treatment (and) unfair trial(s).
- Israel, like America, flouts the rule of law. As a result,
Palestinians have been victimized for over six decades, denied any measure
of justice and freedom. Makhoul and Sa'adat are two of thousands enduring
Israeli savagery, its longstanding practice against Muslim Arabs.
- Stephen Lendman lives in Chicago and can be reached at
email@example.com. Also visit his blog site at sjlendman.blogspot.com
and listen to cutting-edge discussions with distinguished guests on the
Progressive Radio News Hour on the Progressive Radio Network Thursdays
at 10AM US Central time and Saturdays and Sundays at noon. All programs
are archived for easy listening.