SIGHTINGS


 
Is Gravity Broken?
Back To The Drawing
Board For Einstein?
By Alan Boyle
MSNBC www.msnbc.com
From Stig Agermose <Stig_Agermose@online.pol.dk>
9-11-98


 
 
MSNBC -- Is gravity broke? Or is it just the spacecraft? For whatever reason, far-flung probes such as Pioneer 10 and 11 are showing an anomalous slowdown effect. If the observations are correct, that could force a revision of Einstein's theories.
 
THE EFFECT, reported Wednesday by New Scientist magazine, has been showing up for years in analyses of telemetry from Pioneer 10 and 11, which were launched in the early 1970s.
 
"It's just recently that it became unambiguous, and we have no explanation for it," said John Anderson, a planetary scientist at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory and a principal investigator on the Pioneer team.
 
Pioneer 10 is about 6.5 billion miles away from the sun, and Pioneer 11 is more than 4.5 billion miles away. Anderson explained that Pioneer 10 should have reached escape velocity but readings from the spacecraft show that the probe is decelerating by a tiny, constant amount.
 
"If this force continues, then eventually it would just stop and fall back toward the sun," he said. "We thought this thing would go off into interstellar space."
 
In fact, the Pioneer probes bear plaques that would serve as a greeting to extraterrestrials who might happen upon them.
 
The "drag" also appears to affect the Ulysses spacecraft, which is in a polar orbit around the sun, at a distance of about 490 million miles, Anderson said. An analysis of data from the Galileo spacecraft, currently swinging around Jupiter, was less conclusive, he said.
 
Anderson and his colleagues have ruled out fuel problems, aerodynamic drag from the interstellar medium and the effects of celestial bodies. Also, the anomaly hasn't been observed in the movement of the planets or other objects of substantial mass in the solar system.
 
Currently, Anderson said, the prime suspect in the mystery is "something in the hardware that we haven't found" something that would systematically skew the data coming from the spacecraft. But the spacecraft's operators haven't been able to find such a fault, even though they've looked for years.
 
If the effect is real rather than a glitch, astronomers and mathematicians would have to tinker with gravitational theories that have held up for decades.
 
"It could have cosmological significance somehow," Anderson said. "It could be distorting space and time somehow."
 
For now, Anderson sees that as a "low-percentage" possibility. He's prepared a formal paper on the anomalies that has been accepted for publication by the Physical Review Letters. And he's looking forward to new deep-space missions, such as the proposed Pluto-Kuiper Express, which will have a better tracking system and thus could provide more clues in the mystery.
 
"I think it will be something that we'll be working on over the next decade," he said.





SIGHTINGS HOMEPAGE