- Here is your must-read for the month.
- Here is your oh-my-God-I'm-sending-this-piece-to-every-smart-person-I-know
hunk of outstanding, distressing, disquieting media bliss.
- Here it is: an absolutely exceptional
inside scoop on the white-hot world of Sept. 11 conspiracy theories, writ
large and smart by Mark Jacobson over at New York magazine, and it's mandatory
reading for anyone and everyone who's ever entertained the nagging thought
that something -- or rather, far more than one something -- is deeply
wrong with the official line on what actually happened on Sept. 11.
- See, it is very likely that you already
know that Sept. 11 will go down in the conspiracy history books as a far
more sinister affair than, say, the murky swirl of the Kennedy assassination.
You probably already know that much of what exactly happened on Sept.
11 remains deeply unsettling and largely unsolved -- or to put another
way, if you don't know all of this and if you fully and blithely accept
the official Sept. 11 story, well, you haven't been paying close enough
- But on this, the third anniversary of
the launch of Bush's illegal invasion of Iraq by way of whoring the tragedy
of Sept. 11 for his cronies' appalling gain, what you might not know,
what gets so easily forgotten in the mists of time and via the endless
repetition of the orthodox Sept. 11 tale, is the sheer volume, the staggering
array of unanswered questions about just about every single aspect of
Sept. 11 -- the planes, the WTC towers, the Pentagon, the fires, the passengers
and the cell phone calls and the firefighters and, well, just about everything.
It is, when you look closely, all merely a matter of how far down the
rabbit hole you are willing to go.
- Verily, Jacobson, in his New York mag
piece, encounters crackpots and fringe nutballs and those who think Sept.
11 was connected to aliens and electromagnetic fields and the Illuminati.
It can, unfortunately, get a little crazy. But there is also a very smart,
grounded, intelligent and surprisingly large faction -- which includes
eyewitnesses, Sept. 11 widows, former generals, pilots, professors, engineers,
WTC maintenance workers and many, many more -- who point to a rather shocking
pile of evidence that says there is simply no way 19 fanatics with box
cutters sent by some bearded lunatic in a cave could have pulled off the
most perfectly orchestrated air attack of the century. Not without serious
- Whose help? This, of course, is the biggest
question of all, one which many of the more well-researched theories go
a surprisingly long way toward answering.
- You have to sift and sort. There are
disturbing questions about collapse speeds and controlled demolitions
and why the towers fell when the all-steel infrastructure was designed
to easily withstand the temperatures of any sort of fire, even burning
- There are questions of the mysterious,
media-documented blasts deep in the WTC towers that took place after the
planes hit. There are questions of why there was such a short-selling
spree on shares of American Airlines and United Air Lines the day before
the attack, huge doubts about the failures of NORAD and the FAA, the bizarre
case of the missing plane in the Pentagon crash, and also the downing
of Flight 93 where, according to the coroner, no blood or major plane
wreckage was actually found. There is, ultimately, the stunning failure
of the entire multi-trillion-dollar American air-defense system. Just
- There is also the very big question of
what happened to 7 WTC, the only building not hit by anything at all, but
which collapsed anyway, in a perfect controlled-demolition sort of way,
for no reason anyone can sufficiently explain. But which just so happened
to contain vital offices for the IRS, the Department of Defense, the CIA,
the Secret Service, the Securities and Exchange Commission and more.
- But perhaps Jacobson's article is insufficient
for you. Perhaps you have heard much of it before, or you're more of the
visceral type and need to actually see the proofs in order to delve deeper,
have them laid out like gruesome body parts in a mesmerizing autopsy.
- For you, we have the surprisingly compelling
indie documentary "9/11 Loose Change" (Google it), freely available
on the Internet and produced by three very astute and very young and very
strong-willed dudes who managed to cobble together a truly astounding
array of proofs and interviews and evidence, a full 1 hour and 20 minutes'
worth of mesmerizing footage you will not be able to easily forget.
- Or maybe you should peruse one of the
countless Sept. 11 conspiracy sites, many of which link to relevant video
and one of which -- scholarsfor911truth.org -- claims to be "a non-partisan
association of faculty, students, and scholars, in fields as diverse as
history, science, military affairs, psychology, and philosophy, dedicated
to exposing falsehoods and to revealing truths behind 9/11." Start
- Now, it's very true that some of the
more specious conspiracy claims have been largely discredited and proved
false. Some of the more radical "evidence" gathered by theorists
is quite suspect and easily placed in the category of no-way-in-hell.
This is valid. This is as it should be. You have to chew through a lot
of skin and gristle to get to the real meat.
- But oh the meat. The overwhelming quantity,
the bloody, deadly stench of it. Fact is, it is quite impossible to watch
the entire "Loose Change" documentary and not come away just
a little shaken, a little awed by the sheer number of perversely interrelated
facts and aberrant coincidences-that-aren't-coincidences, shaking your
head at how it all seems to irrefutably prove there is far, far more to
the Sept. 11 tragedy than just crazy Osama and his band of zealots, as
you begin to sink into a sighing morass of rage and frustration and suspicion
and mistrust. You almost can't help it.
- Of course, there is another option. There
is another way out. You may, as is the standard cultural default, simply
ignore it all, scoff and roll your eyes and shrug it all off because it's
just too bleak and distasteful to entertain the idea that the dark Sept.
11 thread winds all the way through the NSA and the FBI and the White
House and the Project for the New American Century and Dick Cheney's mangled
soul and God only knows where else.
- But then again, no. You have to look.
You have to try. Knowledge is power, and while the truth may be spurious
and slippery and messy and deep, the pursuit of it is just about the only
thing we have left. Give that up, and all that's left is spiritual numbness,
emotional stasis and death. So what are you waiting for?
- Mark Morford's Notes & Errata column
appears every Wednesday and Friday on SF Gate and in the Datebook section
of the SF Chronicle. To get on the e-mail list for this column, please
click here and remove one article of clothing. Mark's column also has
an RSS feed and an archive of past columns, which includes a tiny photo
of Mark probably insufficient for you to recognize him in the street and
give him gifts. As if that weren't enough, Mark also contributes to the
hot, spankin' SF Gate Culture Blog.
- ©2006 SF Gate