- "The H5N1 virus, which scientists say kills 100
per cent of the birds it infects......
- A wildlife surveillance program that began in August
tested 4,800 ducks in six migratory-bird flyways across Canada. Initial
results have found an H5-type virus in 28 ducks in Quebec and another five
in Manitoba, said Mr. Clark. Results from the other provinces have yet
to come back but they, too, are expected to show some H5 infection.
- Some form of H5 virus is normally found in about 7.4
per cent of all wild fowl, said Mr. Clark."
- The above comments are additional causes for concern.
The misconception that H5N1 kills 100% of the birds it affects is widely
quoted in the media, but is clearly incorrect.
- The WHO warning in the fall of 2004 was due to the fact
that H5N1 from a fatal human case in Vietnam did not cause death in experimental
ducks. Instead the ducks appeared to be healthy and excreted high levels
of stable H5N1. This concern was borne out by surveys of waterfowl in
Vietnam which showed that 70% were H5N1 positive.
- The recent mission report from Russia also detailed about
two dozen species that were H5N1 positive when shot down by hunters, indicating
that asymptomatic waterfowl was widespread. Further support came from the
rapid spread of H5N1 to new areas via migratory birds. After being detected
in long range migratory birds in May at Qinghai Lake, H5N1 was then reported
for the first time in Russia, Kazakhstan, and Mongolia. Now countries
in Europe are reporting H5N1 infections for the first time.
- Although some serotype of influenza is found in a significant
portion of wild birds, the H5 serotype is not found in 7.4%. In Canada,
there have been about 120 deposits at GenBank and only two are H5. One
(H5N2) was detected in 1980 and the other (H5N9) was detected in 1966.
Thus, there have been no H5 isolates reported in the past 25 years, although
that is when most of the deposits from Canada were collected.
- The above comments also fail to detail how many of the
4800 birds have been tested or the frequency of H5 in the positive provinces
or detail the number of species.
- Publication of this data would allow for a more accurate
analysis of the H5 data collected thus far.
- © 2005 Recombinomics. All rights reserved.