- Mobile phone users who live in the countryside are more
likely to develop brain tumours than those in towns and cities, a study
published today shows.
- Researchers found that people from rural areas who had
used a digital mobile for five years or more were up to four times more
likely to be diagnosed with a tumour.
- They claimed the finding was due to handsets operating
at greater power levels when they are further away from transmitters.
- Mobile phone manufacturers rejected the findings, pointing
out that all mobile phones operate at power levels that are within international
- Prof Kjell Hansson Mild, a biologist at ÷rebro
University, Sweden, said: "Mobile phones can use up to 1,000 times
more power when they are far away from a base station.
- "Our research suggests that you are more at risk
of a brain tumour if you live in the countryside and are consistently using
a mobile far from their transmitters."
- When a mobile phone either makes or receives a call,
it initially operates at full power. After measuring the signal strength
coming from the transmitter, it turns itself down to the lowest power possible
without losing the call.
- Transmitter masts are more spaced out in the countryside
and someone using a mobile frequently in rural areas absorbs far more energy
from their handset than someone who uses their phone mainly in towns and
- Prof Mild and Prof Lennart Hardell, also at ÷rebro
University, whose research is published today in the journal Occupational
and Environmental Medicine, identified 1,429 people living in central Sweden
aged 20 to 80 diagnosed with brain tumours between January 1997 and June
2000, and matched them with a control group.
- All participants were asked about phone use, of older
analogue or newer digital models, or cordless phones.
- Those who lived in the countryside who had used digital
mobile phones for more than a year were 56 per cent more likely to have
been diagnosed with a brain tumour than town and city dwellers.
- Among those who had used a digital mobile for more than
five years, those in rural areas were three-and-a half times more likely
to have a tumour than those in urban areas. When those in both groups who
had used their phones the most were compared, the risk was four times greater
in rural areas.
- Alasdair Philips, of PowerWatch, said holding a phone
away from the head after dialling, until a call is answered, could reduce
people's exposure to high power emissions. Dr Michael Clark, of the Health
Protection Agency, said: "The results should be interpreted with caution."
- Mike Dolan, the executive director of the Mobile Operators
Association, said: "All mobile handsets in the UK comply with international
health and safety guidelines which apply whether the phones are used in
rural or urban areas."
- © Copyright of Telegraph Group Limited 2005.