- With the Army and Marines having trouble maintaining
their ranks, it's time to sign up aliens - even illegal aliens - as volunteers
- Max Boot, a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations,
is a columnist for the Los Angeles Times, where this first appeared.
- It is hard to pick up a newspaper these days without
reading about Army and Marine Corps recruiting and retention woes. Nonstop
deployments and the danger faced by troops in Iraq are making it hard for
both services to fill their ranks.
- The same goes for the National Guard and Reserves. (The
Navy and Air Force, which are much less in harm's way, have no such difficulty.)
- Just to stay at their present sizes, the Army and Marines
are shoveling money into more advertising, extra recruiters and bigger
enlistment bonuses. And yet it's clear to everyone (except, that is, President
George W. Bush and Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld) that the U.S.
military is far too small to handle all the missions thrown its way. We
need to not only maintain the current ranks but also to expand them in
order to recover from a 1990s downsizing in which the Army lost 300,000
- Some experts are already starting to wonder whether the
war on terrorism might break the all-volunteer military. But, because reinstating
the draft isn't a serious option (the House defeated a symbolic draft bill
last year, 402 to 2), some outside-the-box thinking is needed to fill up
the ranks. In this regard, I note that there is a pretty big pool of manpower
that's not being tapped: everyone on the planet of military age who is
not a U.S. citizen or permanent resident.
- Since 9/11, Bush has expedited the naturalization process
for soldiers. But, to enlist, the Pentagon requires either proof of citizenship
or a green card. Out of an active-duty force of about 1.4 million, only
108,803 are foreign-born (7 percent) and 30,541 are noncitizens (2 percent).
- This is an anomaly by historical standards: In the 19th
century, when the foreign-born population of the United States was much
higher, so was the percentage of foreigners serving in the military. During
the Civil War, at least 20 percent of Union soldiers were immigrants, and
many of them had just stepped off the boat before donning blue uniforms.
There were even entire units, like the 15th Wisconsin Volunteer Infantry
(the Scandinavian Regiment) and Gen. Louis Blenker's German Division, where
English was hardly spoken.
- The military would do well today to open its ranks not
only to legal immigrants but also to illegal ones and, as important, to
untold numbers of young men and women who are not here now but would like
to come. No doubt many would be willing to serve for some set period in
return for one of the world's most precious commodities - U.S. citizenship.
Open up recruiting stations from Budapest to Bangkok, Cape Town to Cairo,
Montreal to Mexico City. Some might deride those who sign up as mercenaries,
but these troops would have significantly different motives from the usual
soldier of fortune.
- The simplest thing to do would be to sign up foreigners
for the regular U.S. military, but it would also make sense to create a
unit whose enlisted ranks would be composed entirely of non-Americans,
led by U.S. officers and NCOs.
- Call it the Freedom Legion. As its name implies, this
unit would be modeled on the French Foreign Legion, except, again, U.S.
citizenship would be part of the "pay." And rather than fighting
for U.S. security writ small - the way the Foreign Legion fights for the
glory of France - it would have as its mission defending and advancing
freedom across the world. It would be, in effect, a multinational force
under U.S. command - but one that wouldn't require the permission of France,
Germany or the United Nations to deploy.
- The Freedom Legion would be the perfect unit to employ
in places such as Darfur that are not critical security concerns but that
cry out for more effective humanitarian intervention than any international
organization could muster. U.S. politicians, wary (and rightly so) of casualties
among U.S. citizens, might take a more lenient attitude toward the employment
of a force not made up of their constituents. An added benefit is that,
by recruiting foreigners, the U.S. military could address its most pressing
strategic deficit in the war on terrorism - lack of knowledge about other
cultures. The most efficient way to expand the government's corps of Pashto
or Arabic speakers isn't to send native-born Americans to language schools;
it's to recruit native speakers of those languages.
- Similar considerations early in the Cold War led Congress
to pass the Lodge Act in 1950. This law allowed the Army Special Forces
to recruit foreigners not living in the United States with the promise
of citizenship after five years of service. More than 200 Eastern Europeans
qualified as commandos before the Lodge Act expired in 1959. There's no
reason why we couldn't recruit a fresh batch of foreigners today. It would
certainly be easier than trying to sweet-talk more troops out of recalcitrant
allies or, these days, recruiting at U.S. high schools.