- In December 2000, Gore Vidal, termed America's master
essayist by The Washington Post, told "irregularly elected" President-elect
George W. Bush to "rein in the warlords who were seeking $30 billion
a year over and above the 51 percent of the budget that now already goes
- Two-and-a-half years later -- after Sept. 11, Afghanistan
and Osama bin Laden's disappearance, Iraq and Saddam Hussein's vanishing
act -- Vidal summarized what the Bush "warlords" have achieved
in occupying Iraq: "Chaos."
- "Chaos," Vidal told NCR by fax, "until
we either come to our senses and leave -- not likely any time soon -- or
complete the neocon plan so boldly stated by their youthful 'warriors,'
by annexing as much of the Mideast oil states as possible."
- Vidal seems at least farseeing, if not prophetic, in
his assessment of more than a month ago, as the United States finds the
footing in Iraq increasingly unsteady and dangerous.
- As an occupying power in Iraq, U.S. civilian administrators
backed by U.S. soldiers are "downsizing" the national bureaucracy,
handing outa half million pink slips to former officials and military.
Iraqi soldiers are demanding their pay and pensions. It is an uneasy peace.
There is gunfire.
- Americans there and here are paying a price.
- Up to now, said Vidal, while the Bush administration's
"down payment" for Iraqi oil "has been cheap -- the Bill
of Rights," the cost has not been light "for the people -- there
or here." The U.S. cost has been to its civil liberties. Vidal said,
"USA Patriot Acts 1 and 2, the second leaked but not yet sent to Congress,
neatly folds the republic. What next?" he asked rhetorically, "Franklin
- Vidal is accustomed to delivering chilling predictions.
He does not lack a penchant for going on the attack. Even so, it took guts,
post 9/11 and throughout the Iraq war, to criticize the commander-in-chief.
After 9/11 he was the rare writer who did an analytical commentary on the
background to both the Oklahoma City and World Trade Center bombings --
commentary that his customary U.S. outlets refused to publish.
- All this and more was made available late last year in
Perpetual Peace for Perpetual War: How We Got To Be So Hated and Dreaming
War: Blood for Oil and the Cheney-Bush Junta (Nation Books, 2002). They
are collections of his Vanity Fair and Nation columns with added introductions
- Vidal sees the country in the grip of a corporate-oil
patch-military oligarchy. Asked if the Iraq war was an oil patch-White
House deal so huge Americans can't stand back far enough to see it, Vidal
replied, "Kindly Dr. Goebbels used to say that the greater the lie
a government tells (and repeats loudly), the more it will be believed.
Yes, it is -- was -- about oil and, of course, giving the Cheney-Bush junta's
friends like Halliburton vast contracts to rebuild what we have carefully
- He told NCR, "No one will ever see all the details
but the [current] crookedness is unique in our history. Enron was the first
storm warning but no one realized how easily accepted that cluster of capers
would be by a polity marinated in corruption -- as Ben Franklin predicted,
in 1789, as our eventual fate."
- Vidal has become a scourge of the Bush dynasty. The books
reprise writings on what he sees as the Bush family usurpation of the 2000
presidential election, Bush family business connections to the bin Laden
family, the Texas oil patch's pipeline dealings with the Taliban in Afghanistan
and the subsequent war there, why bin Laden was not pursued, and how the
focus shifted to Saddam Hussein and Iraq.
- As a scourge he is a wry one.
- "American politics is essentially a family affair,
as are most oligarchies," he wrote. And he should know. He grew up
in the home of his grandfather, Oklahoma Sen. Thomas P. Gore, in Washington,
D.C., and was close to the Kennedy clan because he was related to Jacqueline
Kennedy. He is distantly related to former Vice President Al Gore, whose
father was a U.S. senator, and Gore Vidal himself was an unsuccessful liberal
candidate for Congress in 1960 in New York and the U.S. Senate in California
- He knows about corruption in politics and oligarchic
- Long before George W. Bush was irregularly ushered into
the White House due to the "Supreme Court's purloining" of the
2000 election, writes Gore, the nation had "previously enjoyed a number
of quietly corrupt elections decently kept from public view."
- He referred to 1888, when Grover Cleveland's plurality
was canceled by the Electoral College's maneuverings, and 1876 when Democrat
Samuel Tilden had a quarter-million more votes than the Republican Rutherford
B. Hayes, but a Congressionally selected commission gave the victory to
Hayes by a single vote.
- Gore (Eugene Luther) Vidal, who lives in Italy but was
contacted by NCR when he was recently in the United States, was born in
1925 at West Point, where his father was an instructor. He graduated from
Philips Exeter Academy, served on an Army supply ship in Alaska in World
War II, and published his first novel, Willawaw, to quote one account,
"at 19 while still in U.S. Army uniform."
- He grew up with the Army and served in the military,
yet he unabashedly regards war as "the ultimate no-win, all-lose option."
- He writes, "Fifty years ago [Feb. 27, 1947], Republican
Sen. Arthur Vandenberg told [President Harry S.] Truman he could have his
militarized economy only if he first 'scared the hell out of the American
people that the Russians were coming.' Truman obliged. The perpetual war
- Vidal continues, "We are now faced with a Japanese
seventh-century-style arrangement: a powerless Mikado ruled by a shogun
vice president and his Pentagon warrior counselors. Do they dream, as did
the shoguns of yore, of the conquest of China?"
- Sept. 11, Vidal writes, "transformed [Bush] into
the cheerleader he had been in prep school. He promised us not only 'a
new war' but 'a secret war' and, best of all, according to the twinkle
in his eye, 'a very long war.' "
- Continued Vidal, "[President James] Madison warned
us at the dawn of our republic, 'Of all enemies to public liberty, war
is, perhaps, the most to be dreaded because it comprises and develops germs
of every other.' "
- Vidal sees other comparisons with the past.
- "The [founding] fathers had such a fear and loathing
of democracy that they invented the Electoral College so the popular voice
of the people could be throttled, much as the Supreme Court throttled Floridians
on Dec. 12  where Bush was entrusting his endangered Florida vote
to the state's governor, his brother, Jeb."
- Historian Vidal was asked if there was a point in U.S.
history when the democracy functioned. He replied, "Before Polk's
1846 war with Mexico in order to acquire California. General -- then Lieutenant
-- Grant said that the Civil War was the vengeance of God upon us for what
we had done to Mexico."
- These two books signal more than Vidal at the top of
his form as a thunderer, however. In listing his collected writings, Vidal
refers to the slim volumes as "pamphlets." It is a distinction
with a subtle warning.
- The pamphleteer is the point on the shaft of political
dissent; the sharp art of a political tradition the established order never
takes kindly to.
- Pamphlets were the spark that helped ignite the American
Revolution. Tom Paine, with his famous pamphlet, Common Sense, could "electrify
the whole of colonial life," wrote John M. Robertson in his 1915 introduction
to Paine's The Age of Reason.
- Vidal, who sees both rights and democracy fast ebbing,
seeks to electrify, too. But the populace, comfortably uninformed and occupied
with its daily self, is inert.
- Arthur Jones is NCR editor-at-large. His e-mail address
- From the Introduction to Perpetual War:
- "In the last six years two dates are to be remembered
for longer than usual in the United States of Amnesia: April 19, 1995,
when a much-decorated infantry soldier called Timothy McVeigh blew up a
federal building in Oklahoma City, killing 168 innocent men, women and
children. Why? McVeigh [who may have committed mass murder to avenge the
government slaughter of the religious cult at Waco] told us at eloquent
length, but our rulers and their media preferred to depict him as a sadistic,
crazed monster. On Sept. 11, 2001, Osama bin Laden and his Islamic terrorist
organization struck at Manhattan and the Pentagon.
- "The Pentagon Junta in charge of our affairs programmed
their president to tell us that bin Laden was an 'evildoer' who envied
us our goodness and wealth and freedom.
- "None of these explanations made much sense, but
our rulers for more than half a century have made sure that we are never
to be told the truth about anything that our government has done to other
people, not to mention, in McVeigh's case, our own.
- "All we are left with are blurred covers of Time
and Newsweek where monstrous figures from Hieronymous Bosch stare out of
us, hellfire in their eyes, while The New York Times and its chorus of
imitators spin complicated stories about mad Osama and cowardly McVeigh,
thus convincing most Americans that only a couple of freaks would ever
dare strike at a nation as close to perfection as any human society can
- That U.S. government policies and actions "might
have seriously provoked McVeigh and bin Laden was never dealt with. Things
just happen out there in the American media and we consumers don't need
to be told the why of anything."
- National Catholic Reporter, August 1, 2003
- This Week's Stories | Home Page | Top of Page
- Copyright © The National Catholic Reporter Publishing
- 115 E. Armour Blvd., Kansas City, MO 64111
- All rights reserved.
- 816-531-0538 FAX: 1-816-968-2280
- Send comments about this Web site to: firstname.lastname@example.org