Rense.com



Pakistan Matches Indian
Troop Withdrawal

By Simon Denyer and Y.P. Rajesh
10-18-2


ISLAMABAD/NEW DELHI (Reuters) - Pakistan said on Thursday it would withdraw troops from the border with India to peacetime locations, in response to a similar gesture from its South Asian rival.
 
As tension between the nuclear-armed neighbours eased, India said Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee might also visit Pakistan early next year -- if a regional summit went ahead as planned.
 
But both sides said the withdrawal of troops would not apply to a tense ceasefire line in the disputed Himalayan region of Kashmir, where the two armies continued to shell and snipe at each other almost on a daily basis.
 
New Delhi continued to rule out direct talks with the Pakistan government over Kashmir, which has soured relations between them since independence and almost brought them to a fourth war in June.
 
After holding state assembly elections in Indian Jammu and Kashmir in September and October, India announced on Wednesday it was ready to begin the phased withdrawal of the hundreds of thousands of soldiers from the border.
 
The brief Pakistani response came after a meeting chaired by President Pervez Musharraf.
 
"The government of Pakistan has decided to withdraw its forces from the Pakistan-India border to their peace-time locations," a statement from the Pakistan Foreign Ministry said. "The pull back will commence shortly."
 
The move signalled an end to the longest and biggest deployment of troops in the region since independence, but left the rival countries still poles apart over Kashmir.
 
"Frankly what we need is not the withdrawal of troops, although that is part of de-escalation, but the solution of the core issue, and that means a dialogue on Kashmir," Pakistani presidential spokesman Major-General Rashid Qureshi told Reuters.
 
India says Pakistan sends Muslim militants across the front line into Kashmir, and India refuses to talk until that stops.
 
"What's needed to start any dialogue with Pakistan is a complete and visible end to the sponsorship of cross-border terrorism and we have seen no change in that," a foreign ministry spokesman said in New Delhi.
 
CONFLICTING SIGNALS
 
In this atmosphere of gradual detente, India sent conflicting signals on Thursday on whether Vajpayee would visit Pakistan to attend a South Asian summit due in the third week of January.
 
Indian External Affairs Minister Yashwant Sinha cast doubt on whether the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation summit would go ahead as planned, but said Vajpayee would attend if it did.
 
"I have said...that if we don't make progress on SAARC issues, there is no point in holding a summit," he said.
 
Sinha's junior minister, Digvijay Singh, earlier told television Vajpayee would attend the talks in what would be his first visit to Pakistan since 1999.
 
Both ministers stressed the visit, if it went ahead, would focus on SAARC and not on Kashmir. "SAARC is a multilateral forum and there is no scope for bilateral talks," Singh said.
 
India's reluctance to talk is partly a reflection of its deep distrust of Pakistan's powerful military, analysts say.
 
But it is also a reflection of the fact that it controls the key valley at the heart of Kashmir, and would prefer an internal solution to the 13-year insurgency in the mainly Muslim region.
 
New Delhi argues that the recent state election in Jammu and Kashmir, where it claims a turnout of more than 40 percent, vindicates its rule there and was a vote against the insurgents.
 
An election in Pakistan last week will bring a civilian prime minister to power for the first time since a 1999 military coup by General Musharraf. But it has not loosened the army's influence over foreign policy, institutionalised through a National Security Council headed by Musharraf himself.
 
If talks did take place -- and there will be significant international pressure for dialogue -- few expect a breakthrough.
 
"Talks between India and Pakistan are more posturing than anything else, because once they get to the table the two sides will see that they do not have much to discuss," said Pakistani political commentator Ayaz Amir. "Their positions are so hard and there is very little they can do to each other."
 
HAND SHAKES
 
Nevertheless, Vajpayee's visit would be the first time a leader of either country has visited their neighbour since Musharraf came to India for a failed bilateral summit in 2001.
 
The two men did shake hands briefly in Nepal in January at this year's summit of SAARC, which also includes Bangladesh, Bhutan, the Maldives and Sri Lanka, but held no bilateral talks.
 
Indian army officers said some of the hundreds of thousands of battle-ready troops could start pulling back from the 3,310-km border as early as Thursday.
 
But there will be no reduction in Kashmir, where both sides exchanged heavy but sporadic artillery and mortar fire overnight on the Siachen glacier, the word's highest battlefield.
 
Military experts say the partial withdrawal would take weeks and front line officers have said it would take months to clear mines from farm fields along the border.
 
Troops were thrilled at the announcement, just before the Diwali holiday in early November and after a harsh winter and scorching summer dug in along the frontier.
 
"The soldiers in the bunkers are particularly happy. People had forgotten them all through the long summer," one senior officer on the front line in Punjab said.
 
India and Pakistan massed a million men along their border running from Kashmir through the Punjab plains down to deserts on the Arabian Sea after a December attack on India's parliament that New Delhi blamed on Pakistan-based Kashmiri separatists.
 
"Definitely there are chances of a fresh flare-up of tension if there is a bad terrorist attack," said former Indian admiral Raja Menon. "I feel Musharraf is not fully in control of these militants but he lacks the courage to say so."
 
 
 
Copyright © 2002 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of Reuters Limited






MainPage
http://www.rense.com


This Site Served by TheHostPros