- The Al-Zaytouna Centre for Studies and Consultations
is a Beirut, Lebanon-based organization engaged in "strategic and
futuristic studies on the Arab and Muslim worlds, (highlighting) the Palestinian
- In spring 2010, it published a Britain-Palestine All
Party Parliamentary Group (BPAPPG) study, including the widespread detention
of Palestinian children titled, "Under Occupation: A Report on the
West Bank," discussed below.
- Under military occupation, Palestinian children are treated
like adults. Each year, about 700 are arrested, brutally interrogated,
and prosecuted in military courts, denying them justice.
- Since 2000 alone, over 7,000 have been brutalized. On
January 31, 2011, 222 Palestinian children were imprisoned, 34 aged 12
- 15. Some at times are 10 or younger. At age 16, they're considered adults
in violation of international law.
- Israel, in fact, brazenly repudiates children's rights
and welfare, treating them like adults, in violation of the UN Declaration
of the Rights of the Child, its Principle 1 saying:
- "Every child, without exception whatsoever, shall
be entitled to (fundamental human and civil) rights, without distinction
or discrimination on account of race, colour, sex, language, religion,
political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth
or other status, whether of himself or of his family."
- They're entitled to special protections and opportunities
to develop physically, mentally, morally, spiritually, and socially in
a healthy normal way under conditions of freedom and dignity - including
their right to life, an adequate standard of living, healthcare, education,
leisure, safety and peace, what Israel denied them for over four decades.
- Instead, they're taken to military detention centers,
harshly interrogated for days without access to lawyers or family members.
In fact, parents and siblings rarely know where they're held or whether
they're alive or dead.
- Moreover, they're mistreated, beaten, terrorized, usually
tortured, hooded, denied food and water for prolonged periods as well as
access to toilets and washing facilities, exposed to extreme heat and cold,
painfully shackled, and deprived of sleep for several days, often in the
- It consists of hands and legs bound to a small chair,
at times from behind to a pipe affixed to the wall, painfully slanted forward,
hooded with a filthy sack, and played loud music nonstop through loudspeakers.
- NGOs like the Public Committee Against Torture in Israel,
Adalah and DCI-Palestine report widespread abuse. In 2009, a sample of
100 sworn affidavits revealed:
- -- 69% of them were beaten, kicked, slapped, or otherwise
- -- 49% were threatened;
- -- 14% held in solitary confinement;
- -- 12% threatened with sexual assault, including rape;
- -- 32% forced to sign confessions in Hebrew most don't
- As a result, from 2001 - 2010, over 645 complaints were
filed against Israeli Security Agency (ISA) interrogators, citing mistreatment
and abuse. So far, no criminal investigations resulted, even for the most
- Based solely on soldiers' testimonies and coerced confessions,
children are usually charged with stone-throwing, whether or not true.
To assure lesser sentences and fines, usually two to six months confinement,
81% plead guilty. Otherwise, they'll be remanded for extended periods,
tried and convicted in kangaroo proceedings, nearly always siding against
- Mahmoud K's experience was typical, a 15-year old boy
from Bethlehem. He was taken to court shackled hands and legs. Wrist restraints
were only removed during proceedings, conducted in Hebrew (with translation
by an Israeli soldier). Intimidating security guards filled the room.
- Mahmoud pleaded not guilty to throwing a Molotov cocktail.
He was detained four months prior to trial. Two other arrested boys signed
confessions, naming him, retracted when they came to court. Both said they
were abused, threatened and coerced to go along. The entire proceeding
lasted an hour. It hardly mattered as guilty as charged nearly always follows.
- Heading to school, another 16-year old youth was arrested
for not having his ID card. Afterward, he was beaten, sent to Etzion detention
camp, handcuffed, blindfolded, and beaten again brutally to get him to
confess to stone-throwing and reveal names of other children with him at
- During interrogation, his head was immersed in cold water,
then hot, then the toilet. Later moved to Adorim camp, he was again beaten,
tortured, held in solitary confinement for 34 days, then on "restrictive
order" at Telmond Prison, in violation of Article 37 of the Convention
on the Rights of the Child (CRC) stating:
- "No child shall be subjected to torture or other
cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment....
- No child shall be deprived of his or her liberty unlawfully
- Every child deprived of liberty shall be treated with
humanity and respect.... (and)
- Every child deprived of his or her liberty shall have
the right to prompt access to legal and other appropriate assistance...."
- CRC also mandates detention as a last resort for the
shortest possible time. Israel does it preemptively, repressively, and
irresponsibly to harass, abuse, inflict bodily and emotional harm, torture
or kill - legalized by authorities decades ago, including harming children
- -- bad food and unsafe water;
- -- poor healthcare or lack of it;
- -- bad sanitation and hygiene;
- -- insect infested cells;
- -- cramped and crowded conditions;
- -- inadequate air and light;
- -- insufficient clothing, blankets and other protections;
- -- no play or recreation;
- -- isolation from the outside world;
- -- no family visits;
- -- the absence of counselors and specialists;
- -- detention with adults, some violent;
- -- solitary confinement;
- -- verbal, physical and sexual abuse; and
- -- no education.
- Against adults and children alike, including women and
girls, nothing is too brutal or extreme. For example, one 15-year old said
he was stripped naked, forced into an extremely painful position, then
burned by lit cigarettes to make him confess.
- Others are tortured to collaborate. A 10-year old said
"They beat me on various parts of my body with plastic hoses. I had
to have a surgical operation to have a platinum transplant in my arm. They
kept me naked for a whole night, handcuffed and blindfolded; and I was
not allowed to go to the toilet for two days!"
- According to the Palestinian Prisoners Club, 95% of children
are tortured, 85% to confess under duress and sign Hebrew documents they
can't read or understand.
- Israel brazenly violates international law, including
in how they treat young children. In fact, harassing, intimidating, threatening,
cuffing, shackling, abusing, torturing and denying due process breaches
Fourth Geneva, the UN Torture Convention, and UN Convention on the Rights
of the Child.
- They're inviolable legal standards Israel doesn't give
a damn about when it comes to Palestinian Arabs. Why should they when international
community leaders raise no accountability issues.
- A Final Comment
- In the Adalah Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in
Israel's March Newsletter, Mahd Bader, a human rights law attorney, headlined,
"Secret Prison for UFOs," saying:
- Facility 1391 is Israel's Guantanamo. Officially it doesn't
exist. Detainees aren't told where they're held. They're kept in darkened
cells, brutally interrogated, and denied outside contact. On January 11,
2011, Israel's Supreme Court again "demonstrated its conservative
nature with respect to human rights in general and the rights of weak population
sectors in particular," effectively approving the facility's existence,
its location still secret.
- In fact, Israel is prohibited from having secret detention
facilities. Those existing should be closed or revealed. Instead, the Court
performed a "balancing act (with) legal hair-splitting and zigzagging.
(It) chose to take the complex, meandering and superfluous road of 'appropriate
balance' and, after examining the clashing interests and rights,"
avoided respecting international and Israeli law.
- As a result, it ruled that detainee rights and their
families are indeed violated. "However, the infringement is proportional....since
the State has suggested an arrangement (to) minimize it." No details
were published or consideration for how often authorities do what they
please, freely violating Court decisions with impunity.
- Nonetheless, the State agreed "not to hold in this
facility citizens of Israel or residents of the occupied territory unless
high military officials order it. Moreover, those detained will only be
for a short time. Even though the Military Judge Advocate General and Ministry
of Justice supervise the facility, many questions and problems remain unanswered.
- Also consider "for whom is that unknown detention
facility intended if the State" won't use it for Israeli Arabs or
Palestinians? Why is it needed and kept secret? How short is "very
short," and why does any court tolerate illegal practices? No satisfactory
answers were provided.
- Given today's extremist Court and Knesset, especially
regarding Muslims, offers more proof that "Israel is knowingly and
surely sliding towards a dark and oppressive regime."
- Today Arabs are persecuted. Tomorrow others. Soon anyone
resisting state authority, no matter how oppressive and lawless. Ahead,
Bader sees what he calls a "Jewish phobiocraticstate," targeting
anyone within or outside the law.
- Stephen Lendman lives in Chicago and can be reached at
email@example.com. Also visit his blog site at sjlendman.blogspot.com
and listen to cutting-edge discussions with distinguished guests on the
Progressive Radio News Hour on the Progressive Radio Network Thursdays
at 10AM US Central time and Saturdays and Sundays at noon. All programs
are archived for easy listening.