- For those who haven't noticed, Israel
opposes a two-state solution. It has been doing everything in its power
to prevent a Palestinian state from emerging and will continue to do so
as long as it can count on the complicity of its powerful friends and on
abundant popular indifference. Under such circumstances, it is incumbent
upon ourselves to ask why Hamas has therefore been ordered - by Israel
and its same powerful friends --to accept "the two-state solution"
especially when, unlike Israel, it has stated clearly and repeatedly that
it would accept a Palestinian state on the lands occupied by Israel in
the 1967 war, the West Bank, the Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem. Indeed,
all of its key spokespeople have said this:Zahar, Haniye, Meshal, and Yassin
and Rantisi before they were murdered.
-
- Judea and Samaria which are, or were,
the northern and southern West Bank, have been subdivided and parceled
out over decades to hundreds of thousands of Jewish settlers for their
houses and orchards and gardens. They have been crisscrossed and circled
with Jewish-only roads that bind the land, the houses and orchards and
gardens, to Israel. They have been manned with guards and gunmen and tanks
and blue and white Israeli flags that defend, protect and assure the settlers,
their houses and orchards and gardens, that they are in fact Israelis belonging
to a single Jewish state.
-
- The settled lands with their settler
families, their houses and gardens, shops and schools, clubs and cafes
and pools, have been mapped and assigned, seized and secured from the Arabs
in the shabby clothes in the rundown villages who live outside of, or have
been forced to leave, the protected colonial zones. The projected frontiers,
the future borders, depend on the disappearance of these Arabs, which is
anxiously anticipated and actively encouraged. Most of the eastern perimeter
of the current state is a concrete wall erasing from view that Other Side,
which is unmentionable in polite company. The eastern perimeter wall will
soon be the western perimeter wall because the acting Israeli Prime Minister,
Ehud Olmert, has just announced that the rest of the unincorporated West
Bank land will soon be annexed to Israel: The Jordan Valley, the West Bank's
border with the state of Jordan, now to be Israel's eastern border with
the state of Jordan, will also be secured by the wall and off-limits to
"non-Israelis," meaning Palestinians, who will then be fully
encircled in their stagnant reservations unable to access the outside world.
-
- In the same breath as he announces this
latest unilateral declaration of confiscated land for a Jewish State, Olmert
announces a sanctions regime against the Palestinians of the occupied territories
for refusing to believe that this land transformation in which one society
is strengthened and expanded and the other is dissolved into a thousand
pieces is actually the two-state solution.
-
- Israel allots to itself first use of
the natural resources, especially water, from the territory it has appropriated
or surrounded. An army of thieves and wreckers has turned the remainder
-- the pot-holed roads, the untended groves, the homes, the schools, the
mosques and churches, the hospitals, universities, shops and remaining
civil institutions -- into a series of impassable mazes, a legal no-man's-land,
where travel restrictions, permits, coded IDs, passes, random searches,
incursions and arbitrary accusations reduce the inhabitants into suspicious
beings without names, faces, addresses or rights; a collective villain
to be de-educated and de-nationalized and, one day perhaps, deported for
the sake of the Israeli raison d'etre. It is becoming as difficult for
travelers from abroad to visit the occupied territories as it is for the
rightful inhabitants to move freely among them. It is therefore more difficult
for outsiders to corroborate that the dangers they are warned against come
directly from Israel, not the hapless people they have besieged. The daily
threat to life and property is growing, not abating.
-
- For those who haven't noticed, there
is no sign of this process coming to an end. Instead, in addition to the
bizarre demand that Hamas accept the two-state solution that Israel has
categorically rejected and each day renders even more geographically impossible,
another two demands are added to it: Hamas must recognize Israel
and it must renounce violence. In other words, it must recognize a state
whose policies and whose leaders have worked tirelessly for decades to
deny, undo, renounce, prevent and reject the existence both of Palestinians
and of Palestine -- not only in the present and future but also through
erasing the past. Still, our media take it upon themselves to show the
world a circus-mirror reality, grotesque in its distortions, in which a
democratically elected government-without-a-state and its trampled, largely
destitute people are made out to be holding hostage the hoodlums that are
busy stomping them to death.
-
- While they are being stomped, shot, beaten,
demolished, assassinated, intimidated, robbed, despoiled, starved, uprooted,
dispossessed, harassed, insulted and killed with bullets, missiles, armored
bulldozers, tanks, helicopter gun-ships, cluster-bombs, fleshettes, fighter-bombers,
semi-automatic submachine guns, sonic booms, tear gas, electrified fences,
blockades, closures and walls, they must renounce violence so that the
hoodlums won't get hurt. If they defend themselves they lose. If they complain,
they are insincere; if they ask for something in return, they are untrustworthy;
If they ask for a fair hearing, they are advancing an "agenda";
If they hit back randomly, they are an instrument of terror. So when the
furies of the thousands of dead, tens of thousands of wounded and detained,
and millions of bound and gagged rise up together in a whirlwind to protest,
they will be pointed to as evidence of innate evil that must justifiably
be contained, justifiably occupied, with justified indignation and bottomless
financial aid.
-
- Hamas' reward for coming to power just
in time to provide all the aspiring Sharons the most perfect, served-up-on-a-silver-platter
pretext for continuing their well-worn policies with a vengeance, has been
for the Kadima party -- the party of the future-- to announce that it will
put the Palestinians on a starvation diet for presuming to exercise their
rights. Hamas' reward for verifying the smashing success of Israel's goal
to destroy Fatah has been Israel's insistence that it abide by all the
agreements, treaties and accords that Fatah, essentially the PA, signed
but which Israel shredded page by page. With every new brick laid for the
settlements, every new road paved to Ariel, Maale Adumim, Illit, Gush Etzion
and beyond, with every permit denied for work, education, medical care
and travel, every truck left waiting with rotting produce at Sufa and Karni,
every tax and customs dollar stolen from a people interned on their own
land, Israel parades its contempt for human decency and gets standing ovations
in the US Congress and elsewhere.
-
- When Osama Bin Laden opines that it is
legitimate for al-Qaida to murder Americans because, as citizens in a democratic
country, they are responsible for their government, "civilized"
society erupts, appropriately, in indignation. When Dov Weisglass and his
smug, sadistic associates advocate appalling varieties of collective punishment
against Palestinians for having had the audacity to democratically replace
the failed Fatah with Hamas, "civilized" society nods its head
in sanctimonious approval.
-
- For those who haven't noticed, Israel
opposes a two-state solution. It also opposes a one-state and a bi-national
state, a federated secular state, and the zillion interim-state solutions
that have been drawn up and debated and argued over the years. It opposes
them because it opposes the presence of another people on land it has claimed
as the exclusive patrimony of the Jews. This has to be the starting point
for effective activism against the racist and hegemonic vision that Israel
is implementing and the US guaranteeing, not faraway discussions on the
most ideal solution. An effective opposition must not retreat into a slumbering
or sidetracked lethal indifference.
-
- Jennifer Loewenstein is a Visiting Research
Fellow at Oxford University's Refugee Studies Centre. She has lived and
worked in Gaza City, Beirut and Jerusalem and has traveled extensively
throughout the Middle East, where she has worked as a free-lance journalist
and a human-rights activist.
|
