- For more than six months now, Ernst Zundel has been held
without charge in solitary confinement in Canada on the pretext that he
a threat to national security. In fact, this 64-year-old German-born writer,
publisher and civil rights activist is a political prisoner and a victim
of great injustice.
-
- Who is this man, and why is his case important?
-
- Zundel was arrested at his home in Tennessee on Feb.
5, where he had been living peacefully with his wife, Ingrid Rimland, on
the pretext that he missed an interview date with immigration authorities.
Two weeks later he was deported to Canada, even though his wife is an American
citizen.
-
- Claiming that he is a national security threat, Canadian
authorities have been holding Zundel since Feb. 19. The Canadian Security
Intelligence Service (CSIS) - something like the American FBI - supports
this charge by citing tenuous and years-old ties by Zundel to "white
supremacist" groups. While acknowledging that he is not violent himself,
CSIS also argues that material published by Zundel might cause "like-minded
individuals to engage in violence."
-
- There is absolutely no basis for the "security threat"
charge. Zundel's life is an open book. He is a peaceful man with no record
of violence. During the 40 years he lived in Canada, he was never convicted
of a crime. In fact, he has himself been a victim of hate and violence.
He survived at least three attempts on his life, including a devastating
arson attack against his residence.
-
- Jewish groups are demanding that Zundel be deported to
Germany, where he faces years of imprisonment for the "thought crime"
of "denying the Holocaust." ("Holocaust denial" is
against the law in Germany, France, Switzerland and some other European
countries.)
-
- Zundel is in prison not because his views are unpopular,
or because he's a "security risk." He's in prison because Jewish
groups want him there. He's a prisoner because he promotes views that the
Jewish-Zionist lobby considers harmful to its interests.
-
- This lobby is the decisive, critical factor in the decades-old
campaign to silence him. The only sustained and institutionalized effort
to imprison him has come from this lobby, which includes the Simon Wiesenthal
Center, the Canadian Jewish Congress, the Canadian Holocaust Remembrance
Association, and the League for Human Rights of B'nai B'rith (with the
Anti-Defamation League, its counterpart in the US).
-
- A few prominent Canadians have been speaking out against
the unjust treatment of Ernst Zundel.
-
- One such person is Bill Dunphy, a veteran investigative
journalist and editor for the daily Hamilton Spectator. He spent six years
probing Canada's "white supremacist" movement, and got to know
Zundel personally. Although he has no sympathy for Zundel's views, in a
hard-hitting column (Hamilton Spectator, May 14) he told readers:
-
- "Our government has seized and branded Ernst Zundel,
stripped him of his human rights, tried him in secret and found him wanting,
and will now hand him over to a foreign government anxious to throw him
in jail...
-
- "... Zundel - who did this country a favour by wiping
off the books our disgraceful False News laws - has never once been convicted
of a criminal offence in this country, never once found to have violated
the hate crime laws that rest snugly around the throat of free expression
in this country.
-
- "Calculating correctly that there was no political
cost, no 'down side, to slipping on the jackboots to kick a reviled old
man out of our country' our government cobbled together their best insults
and innuendo, and Lord knows what secret 'evidence' and branded Ernst Zundel
a threat to national security.
-
- "I know this man, his local and international contacts
and I know this movement. And after reading the 58-page 'unclassified,
summary of the government's case, I can assure you there is no justice
here. Their 'evidence' is riddled with errors and misinformation, hearsay
and inflammatory innuendo. Dead men walk again, and the shattered bits
of shoddy secret networks long since collapsed under the weight of their
own ineptitude are made whole and menacing once again. It is a shameful
piece of dishonest, unreliable tripe."
-
- The trendy Toronto weekly Eye pointed out in an editorial
(May 15) that "declaring Zundel a terrorist now is not the result
of any startling new information," but rather 'it has to do with political
pressure' ..." The paper added:
-
- "The new security certificate admits Zundel has
'virtually no history of direct personal engagement in acts of serious
violence.' It labels him a terrorist partly because he 'seeks to destroy
the multicultural fabric and underpinnings of Canadian society.' Citing
opposition to official multiculturalism as a type of terrorism risks expanding
the war on terror to include everyone to the right of Pierre Trudeau.
-
- "Anti-terrorism provisions should not be used as
a catch-all solution. Misapplying terminology in this way damages its credibility,
and undermines the efforts against real terrorism. It has also, of course,
damaged the integrity of our refugee system."
-
- Similar concerns have been voiced by the daily Times
Colonist of Victoria, British Columbia. In an editorial, "Even Zundel
Merits Fairness" (May 9), the paper declared:
-
- "... The way the federal government is trying to
get rid of Zundel is wrong - it is using law that is so sweeping in its
scope that it may be," as Zundel's lawyer Doug Christie argues, unconstitutional.
It would allow him to be deported on evidence that amounts to mere assumption
and subject him to a kangaroo court process where no defence can be mounted.
-
- "The Canadian Security and Intelligence Service
calls Zundel the patriarch of Canada's white supremacist movement."
It argues he is a risk to national security - a finding essential for his
deportation under this procedure - because he is trying to 'destroy the
multicultural fabric and underpinnings of Canadian society.'
-
- "...Most Canadians would be surprised to learn that
the country's multicultural fabric could be torn apart or society toppled
by Zundel's rants which are not, in fact, broadcast widely. But this is
the basis for CSIS's security certificate against Zundel."
-
- The Canadian Association for Free Expression (CAFE),
a leading free speech advocacy group, is demanding Zundel's immediate
release. "Mr. Zundel is quite literally a political prisoner,"
says CAFE director Paul Fromm, who has also been acting as Zundel's legal
representative in his detention hearings. "He is being held in solitary
confinement solely for the non-violent expression of his political views."
-
- The allegation that Zundel might be a threat to national
security "is mischievous nonsense," says Fromm. "Zundel
has been politically active in Canada for 40 years. He's a public figure.
His writings and speeches are available on-line. He,s been investigated
for years by the police. He's an open book. Zundel has never advocated
or practised violence, nor have his followers," Fromm adds. "He's
a pacifist and a publisher."
-
- A Life of Struggle
-
- Ernst Zundel, a towering figure in the worldwide Holocaust
revisionist movement, was born in 1939 in a small town in the Black Forest
region of southwestern Germany. He emigrated to Canada at the age of 19,
where he soon married and became the father of two sons. It wasn,t long
before he made a name for himself as a successful graphic artist whose
work appeared, for example, on the front cover of Canada's national news
magazine, Maclean's.
-
- Setting aside a thriving career, he resolved to dedicate
himself to the great task, as he sees it, of redeeming the sullied reputation
of his fellow Germans. Through his Samisdat publishing house he distributed
worldwide a prodigious quantity of books, booklets, leaflets, newsletters,
and audio and video cassettes. Simon Wiesenthal, the well-known "Nazi
hunter," has called Zundel the world's number one distributor of allegedly
dangerous literature and cassettes.
-
- He has written countless booklets, newsletters and essays.
He is a prodigious publisher, a one-man public relations firm, and an able
public speaker and organizer. A dauntless leader in struggle against apparently
insurmountable odds and seemingly invincible adversaries, no revisionist
is more tenacious, dedicated and courageous.
-
- Ernst Zundel, who sometimes describes himself as a "Swabian
peasant" is an outgoing, good-humored man who is blessed with a rare
combination of unflagging optimism and practical ability. He maintains
this infectious spirit even under very trying conditions. He is an unusually
alert and sensitive individual with a keen understanding of human nature.
He knows how to persuade, cajole and encourage his supporters to give their
best for the greater good. He inspires confidence, loyalty and affection.
-
- Zundel is probably best known for his central role in
the "Holocaust Trials" of 1985 and 1988. He was brought to court
in Toronto on a charge of "publishing false news," and specifically
for publishing a reprint edition of a booklet entitled Did Six Million
Really Die?.
-
- To wage the legal battle that was forced upon him, he
brought together an impressive international team of revisionist scholars,
legal specialists, researchers, and many others. From numerous libraries
and archives in North America and Europe, this group assembled at "Zundelhaus"
one of the most impressive collections of evidence anywhere on this chapter
of history.
-
- Zundel,s two lengthy trials - the 1985 trial lasted two
months, and the 1988 trial lasted four months - have been the closest thing
anywhere to full scale debates on the Holocaust issue. For the first time
ever, "Holocaust survivors"and Holocaust historians were closely
and critically questioned under oath about their claims and views.
-
- Among those who testified on Zundel's behalf in the two
trials were Robert Faurisson, David Irving, Mark Weber, William Lindsey,
Udo Walendy, and Bradley Smith. As a result of the two trials, an enormous
quantity of compelling evidence refuting the Holocaust extermination story
was presented to the court and thereby was made part of the permanent public
record. The most important of this evidence was the historic testimony
of American gas chamber expert Fred Leuchter about his on-site forensic
examination of the alleged extermination gas chambers in Poland.
-
- Zundel was found guilty in the 1985 trial, but the verdict
was set aside by the provincial appeals court. It ruled that the judge
in that trial had, among other things, given improper instructions to the
jury, and had improperly excluded defense evidence. In May 1988, at the
conclusion of the second Zundel trial, the jury declared him guilty. A
few days later, he was sentenced to nine months imprisonment.
-
- On appeal, Canada's Supreme Court threw out the conviction,
declaring on August 27, 1992, that the archaic "false news" law
under which he had been convicted was a violation of the country's Charter
of Rights. This was not only a personal vindication by Canada's highest
court; Ernst Zundel secured an important victory for the rights of all
Canadians.
-
- Zundel's next great legal battle was fought out before
the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal in Toronto on charges, instigated by
Jewish groups, of promoting "hatred or contempt" against Jews
through the "Zundelsite" Internet web site (www.zundelsite.org),
operated by Ingrid Rimland from the United States. In this legal action,
as the Tribunal's presiding Commissioner declared, the truth or validity
of the supposedly "hateful" items was not a consideration. The
Tribunal ultimately ruled against Zundel, declaring the "Zundelsite"
to be unlawful.
-
- After four decades in Canada, including a failed effort
to acquire Canadian citizenship, he moved to the United States, where he
married Ingrid in January 2000. For two years they lived quietly in the
mountain region of eastern Tennessee.
-
- Of this remarkable man, Robert Faurisson wrote in 1988:
"Zundel may once again go to prison for his research and beliefs or
be threatened with deportation. All this is possible. Anything may happen
when there is an intellectual crisis and a realignment of historical concepts
of such a dimension. Revisionism is the great intellectual adventure of
the end of this century. Whatever happens, Ernst Zundel is already the
victor."
- _______
-
- Mark Weber (weber@ihr.org) is director of the Institute
for Historical Review. He was born in Portland, and was educated in his
home town, Chicago, Munich and Bloomington (Indiana). The IHR is a not-for-profit
educational and publishing enterprise dedicated to truth and accuracy in
history. For further information, see the IHR web site (www.ihr.org), or
write to: IHR, P.O. Box 2739, Newport Beach, CA 92659, USA.
-
- This essay originally appeared in the October 2003 issue
of Community News (P.O. Box 191677, Sacramento, CA 95819, USA. thetruthisback@yahoo.com).
-
- http://www.ihr.org/news/030923Zundel.html
|
